Comparison Guide

Trade In vs Sell Privately — What's Better?

In Ontario, trading in your vehicle can save you hundreds in HST. Here's an honest side-by-side breakdown to help you decide.

FactorTrade-In at DealerPrivate Sale
Ontario HST Savings✓ HST only on the net purchase price✗ No tax savings
Speed of Sale✓ Same day decision✗ Weeks or months
Effort Required✓ We handle everything✗ Photos, ads, showings, test drives
Sale PriceFair market valuePotentially higher price
Personal Safety✓ Safe, professional transaction✗ Strangers visiting your home
Payment Application✓ Instantly applies toward purchase✗ Separate transactions
Paperwork✓ We handle all documentation✗ UVIP, bill of sale, ownership transfer

The Ontario HST Savings Example

In Ontario, when you trade in your vehicle at a licensed dealer, HST is only charged on the difference between the purchase price and trade-in value — not the full vehicle price.

New vehicle price:$25,000
Trade-in value:- $10,000
HST calculated on:$15,000
HST (13%):$1,950
vs. private sale HST:$3,250
HST savings by trading:$1,300

Ready to Get Your Valuation?

Know what your car is worth before you decide to trade or sell.